Former NFL receiver suggests the Green Bay Packers should trade Rashan Gary to the Browns for Myles Garrett.

A Shocking Trade Proposal Emerges

The NFL offseason always brings unexpected trade rumors and bold suggestions, but a recent proposal involving the Green Bay Packers and Cleveland Browns has turned heads. A former NFL receiver has suggested that the Packers should trade star pass rusher Rashan Gary to the Browns in exchange for All-Pro defensive end Myles Garrett.

While this is purely speculative, the idea of a blockbuster swap between two of the league’s most dominant edge rushers has sparked debate among fans and analysts. Would this trade make sense for both teams?

Rashan Gary’s Rise in Green Bay

Since being drafted by the Packers in 2019, Rashan Gary has developed into one of the premier edge rushers in the league. His relentless motor, elite athleticism, and ability to generate pressure have made him a cornerstone of Green Bay’s defense.

Gary signed a four-year, $96 million contract extension in 2023, solidifying his role as a long-term defensive leader. His presence on the field is undeniable, and he played a crucial role in helping the Packers defense remain competitive during the 2024 season.

Myles Garrett: A Generational Talent

Myles Garrett is widely considered one of the best defensive players in the NFL. The Browns’ star edge rusher has been a dominant force since being selected as the first overall pick in the 2017 NFL Draft.

A multiple-time Pro Bowler and All-Pro selection, Garrett’s combination of power, speed, and technical skill makes him nearly unstoppable. He recorded another elite season in 2024, continuing to prove why he is a franchise-defining player.

Despite his individual brilliance, the Browns have struggled to establish themselves as a consistent Super Bowl contender. If Cleveland believes they need a shake-up, moving Garrett in exchange for a younger, highly talented pass rusher like Gary could be a strategic move.

Would This Trade Make Sense for the Packers?

For Green Bay, acquiring Myles Garrett would be a game-changing move. He would instantly elevate their defense to an elite level, pairing with players like Kenny Clark and Jaire Alexander to create one of the most feared units in the league.

However, the Packers have already invested heavily in Rashan Gary, and moving on from him so soon after signing his extension could be a tough pill to swallow. Additionally, Garrett carries a massive contract, and Green Bay would need to navigate the salary cap implications.

Would the Browns Be Willing to Move Garrett?

From Cleveland’s perspective, trading Myles Garrett would be a shocking decision. He is the face of their defense and one of the most valuable players in the NFL. However, if they see Rashan Gary as a younger, slightly less expensive option who can still provide elite production, they might consider the move.

The Browns have a strong roster but are still searching for a way to take the next step in the AFC. If they believe that shifting assets and acquiring Gary could provide better long-term flexibility, this trade could be explored.

The Verdict: Highly Unlikely but Intriguing

While the idea of a Rashan Gary-for-Myles Garrett trade is fascinating, it is highly unlikely to happen. Both players are integral to their respective teams, and trading either would require significant reasoning beyond just a talent swap.

The Packers view Gary as a foundational piece, and the Browns see Garrett as their defensive anchor. Unless major contract or locker room issues arise, both teams are more likely to continue building around their star pass rushers rather than swapping them.

Still, the NFL offseason is full of surprises, and bold trade ideas like this keep fans engaged in the speculation. Even if this trade never materializes, it sparks an interesting conversation about roster construction and the value of elite pass rushers in today’s game.